Girdling Roots: How to Spot One and When to Cut It

Michael Kahn, Sacramento homeowner and lifelong gardener
Michael Kahn
9 min read
Thick roots curving across one another at the base of a tree trunk in dry grass

A girdling root is a root that wraps around the base of a trunk instead of growing out away from it. As both the trunk and the root thicken, the root squeezes the trunk and chokes off the water and sugar moving up and down just under the bark. The Morton Arboretum names Norway maple as the most susceptible tree, and says a tree whose girdling roots started in a nursery pot “seldom survives more than a decade in the landscape.”

Most girdling roots are fixable if you find them early, and some are better left alone. Which kind you have comes down to how big the root is and whether the trunk has already grown around it.

What does a girdling root do to a tree?

The best look inside comes from a 1981 study in the Journal of Arboriculture. Researchers dissected a 25-year-old Norway maple that was declining in a lawn. They expected one girdling root. When they excavated, they found four, together wrapping about 70 percent of the trunk.

Where the roots pressed, the bark had been crushed from 1.5 to 3 centimeters thick down to a flaky layer about a millimeter thick, and the water-conducting wood in the squeezed zone had about a tenth of its normal capacity. The girdling roots themselves were barely compressed and “appeared to remain functional.” That detail matters later: the root strangling the tree is often one of the roots feeding it.

Where do girdling roots come from?

Mostly from the nursery and the planting hole. A study of 120 parkway trees dug up 3 to 10 years after planting found that at least two-thirds of their girdling roots started within two years of transplanting, and in four of the five species, at least half were already there on the day the tree went in the ground. Forest trees that were never transplanted had none.

The usual causes, from Colorado State Extension and the Morton Arboretum:

  • Pot-bound roots. Roots hit the container wall and circle, then keep circling after planting.
  • Repotting into bigger containers. Each move up can bury circling roots deeper inside the ball, where you can’t see them.
  • Planting too deep. Buried roots grow upward toward air and often cross the trunk on the way.
  • Mulch or soil piled against the trunk. Roots grow up into it and wrap the base.

Planting depth has the strongest research behind it. In a study of red maples planted at grade, 6 inches deep and 12 inches deep, girdling roots encircled 14 percent of the trunk at grade, 48 percent at 6 inches and 71 percent at 12 inches after just three years. If you suspect your tree went in too deep, our guide to a tree planted too deep covers how to check and fix the depth itself.

Which trees get girdling roots?

Any tree can, but some are much more prone. Colorado State’s list of girdling-prone species: crabapple, green ash, hackberry, littleleaf linden, red maple and poplars. Norway maple tops the Morton Arboretum’s list.

Prone doesn’t mean doomed. A survey of 410 street Norway maples in Ann Arbor, Michigan, all 54 to 57 years old, found girdling roots on 336 of them, about 82 percent. The researchers found no significant effect on leaf color, leaf size or crown dieback that they could pin on the girdling. Most of those trees were only lightly girdled, and they kept growing.

What are the signs of a girdling root?

Look at the base of the trunk first.

  • A flat or pinched side where the trunk meets the soil, sometimes with a bulge above it.
  • No flare. A healthy trunk widens as it meets the ground. In the Sacramento Tree Foundation’s words, “If the trunk resembles a straight stick in the dirt, the root flare is buried,” and a buried flare is where girdling roots hide.
  • A visible root running sideways across the base.

Then the canopy. Colorado State Extension lists swelling above and below the girdling root and “generally poor health or dieback without any obvious cause.” The Morton Arboretum describes decline and dieback of the crown. And University of Minnesota Extension warns that trees with stem girdling roots “may blow over or break off at the ground line.”

Crown dieback and thinning look a lot like drought stress, root rot or verticillium wilt. The only sure sign is seeing the root. If the canopy is what tipped you off, our guide to the signs of a dying tree helps sort out the other causes.

How do you find a girdling root?

Dig for it. Penn State Extension educator Thomas Ford checks trees with a small masonry trowel, excavating around the trunk “to a depth of 4–6 inches,” and reports that “almost 80% of the trees I have examined have had one or more stem girdling roots.”

You won’t usually have to go deep. In the Ann Arbor maple survey, the girdling roots averaged about 2.5 inches below the surface, and most sat within the top 3.4 inches. The same survey found an average of 2.4 girdling roots per girdled tree, so once you find one, keep going around the trunk.

For a big tree, or a job that needs more than a trowel, an ISA-certified arborist can clear the soil with an air spade, a compressed-air tool that blows soil off roots without cutting them.

Should you cut a girdling root?

The sources give several different size rules, and they don’t measure the same thing:

SourceCut it yourself if…Call an arborist if…
Penn State Extensionthe root is under 2 inches in diameterit’s over 2 inches
UF/IFAS Extensionits diameter is under 25% of the trunk diameter (measured 4.5 ft up)it’s over 25%
Sacramento Tree Foundation(no homeowner cut size given)the work involves roots over 1 inch

Penn State’s advice for the small ones is direct: “take the courage to go ahead and carefully cut the girdling root.” I’d use the 2-inch line for a homeowner job and the UF percentage as a second check on a smaller tree, where a 2-inch root can be a big share of the trunk.

How the root sits matters as much as its size. Colorado State Extension draws the line this way:

  • Pressing on the trunk but not grown into it: “Circling roots not embedded into the trunk should be cut and removed.” Cut it back to where it starts growing away from the trunk, and the tree will likely recover without long-term effects.
  • Embedded, with bark grown over it: cut the root, but leave the embedded section in place. Prying it out opens the trunk to decay. Colorado State’s verdict on these trees: they “may or may not survive.”

When to cut. Penn State Extension recommends early spring or late fall, while the tree is dormant and moving less water. In the Sacramento Valley that means roughly November through February.

What to cut with. A sharp pair of bypass pruners like the Felco F2 handles roots up to about an inch, and a folding pruning saw like the Silky GomBoy does the rest. Penn State’s advice is to “Select the smallest tool you can practically use to avoid unintentionally injuring your plant,” and to scrape the soil off the cut point first so you don’t dull the blade. Their own example, a 3-inch girdling root on a sycamore cut with a hand saw, took about 30 minutes and was “labor-intensive and tedious.”

Does cutting a girdling root save the tree?

Extension services are more hopeful than the research. Penn State Extension says root collar excavation and girdling root removal on larger trees “can improve their health and in many cases, it is the only thing that can save it from early death and removal.” The Morton Arboretum is more cautious: on big established trees, removal “may cause enough damage to the root system to hasten the decline,” and “It is difficult to predict if removing the roots will be more damaging than leaving them alone.”

A 2014 research review in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry found that girdling root removal is common practice but lacks research validation, and that on young Norway maples, multiple new roots sometimes regrew from the cut.

Here’s how I’d weigh it. Cut a small root pressing on a young tree, and the sooner the better. When a big root has grown into the trunk of a mature tree that still looks healthy, get an arborist’s eye on it before anyone cuts, because it may be holding the tree up and feeding it at the same time. If the tree is large, already in steep decline and wrapped in embedded roots, removal and a better-planted replacement is often the smarter money.

After a cut, Penn State says to watch the canopy. Some dieback can follow in the part of the crown that root fed. Prune out dead branches as they show up, keep the tree watered through summer, and leave the fertilizer in the garage.

How do you prevent girdling roots on the next tree?

The fix happens on planting day, and it takes ten minutes.

  1. Slide the tree out of the pot and look. Roots circling the outside or the top of the ball are the start of tomorrow’s girdling roots.
  2. Shave the root ball. UF/IFAS Extension says to “shave off the outer inch of the tree’s root ball with a sharp shovel or handsaw.” Scoring a few vertical slashes down the sides doesn’t fix it; the 2014 review found slashing leaves descending and kinked roots in place.
  3. Find the root flare and plant it at or just above the soil line. Colorado State says that on girdling-prone species like red maple and linden, the top structural root should sit within the top inch of soil.
  4. Keep mulch off the trunk. A flat ring 2 to 4 inches deep with a gap at the trunk, never a volcano. Our guide to mulching a tree covers the details.

Shaving the root ball feels brutal, but it doesn’t set the tree back. In a five-year study of red maples and Chinese elms, correcting the roots at planting sharply cut trunk circling and didn’t measurably hurt growth or anchorage. The Sacramento Tree Foundation puts it well: “Don’t miss your only chance to liberate the rootball before planting!”

Our guides to root-bound nursery trees and how to plant a tree walk through the rest of planting day, and if your tree is a Japanese maple, our page on Japanese maple diseases covers girdling roots alongside the usual leaf problems.

Frequently asked questions

What is a girdling root? A girdling root is a root that grows around the base of the trunk, usually at or just below the soil line, instead of growing out away from it. As the trunk and the root both thicken, the root squeezes the trunk and cuts off the water and sugar moving through the outer layers of wood and bark.

Can a girdling root kill a tree? Yes, slowly. The Morton Arboretum says a tree with girdling roots from a nursery pot seldom survives more than a decade in the landscape, and on balled-and-burlapped trees the decline can take 20 to 30 years. University of Minnesota Extension adds that trees with stem girdling roots may blow over or break off at the ground line.

Can I cut a girdling root myself? For small roots, yes. Penn State Extension says a girdling root under 2 inches in diameter can be cut carefully by a homeowner. For anything larger, or a root that has grown into the trunk, have an ISA-certified arborist look at it first, because a big root may be holding the tree up.

When is the best time to cut a girdling root? Penn State Extension recommends early spring or late fall, while the tree is dormant and not moving much water. In the Sacramento area that roughly means November through February. Avoid summer cuts.

How do you prevent girdling roots? Fix the roots before you plant. Shave off the outer inch of a container root ball with a sharp spade or saw, as UF/IFAS Extension recommends, remove any roots circling the top of the ball, and plant with the root flare at or just above the soil line.

The planting and care products linked across this site are collected in the Tree Planting and Watering Essentials list on my Amazon storefront.

girdling roots stem girdling roots root girdling girdling roots maple root collar excavation circling roots tree decline