Tree Planted Too Deep? How to Find the Root Flare and Fix It
Look at where your tree’s trunk meets the ground. On a properly planted tree, the trunk widens there into the start of its main roots. That widening is the root flare, and it should sit at or just above the soil line. If the trunk goes straight into the ground like a fence post, the flare is buried and the tree was planted too deep. The Sacramento Tree Foundation puts it plainly: “If the trunk resembles a straight stick in the dirt, the root flare is buried.”
It’s common, it’s often fixable, and it’s worth checking even on a tree that looks fine.
How often are trees planted too deep?
Most of the time. When Bartlett Tree Experts excavated 417 recently planted trees, 93 percent had buried root collars, according to a 2009 research review in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry. The average depth to the first root ran from about 3 inches in Charlotte and Cape Cod to just over 6 inches on Long Island.
A lot of that burial happens before the tree reaches you. Iowa State Extension notes that the flare on container trees is sometimes “buried by soil during the spring potting operation, at times by an inch or more.” That’s why you can’t trust the soil line in the pot. Iowa State’s advice for the planting hole: dig to the height of the root mass after you find the flare, which “is not necessarily the container’s height.”
How deep is too deep?
Less than most people think. In a Texas study of five landscape plants, including crape myrtle and oleander, “Adverse effects were demonstrated when root collars were located as little as 7.6 cm (3 in) below grade on all taxa tested.” Planting 3 inches above grade improved growth over at-grade planting in some cases.
The effect can be severe. In a South Carolina study, half of the Yoshino cherries planted 6 or 12 inches deep died within two years, while every cherry planted at grade survived. Red maples in the same study lived but grew girdling roots around much more of their trunks the deeper they were planted.
Not every deep tree dies, and one study is worth keeping in mind before you panic. Researchers who examined street trees in Illinois and Washington concluded that “deep root systems are not causing widespread decline and losses to urban trees in the first ten years after planting,” while finding deep roots were one of several factors in poorer growth. Their 2012 paper doesn’t change the planting advice. Every source still says to plant at grade. It does mean a deep 15-year-old tree in good health is not an emergency.

What are the signs of a tree planted too deep?
- No visible flare. The trunk enters the soil as a straight column.
- Girdling roots. Buried trees push roots up toward air, and those roots often wrap the trunk. Our guide to girdling roots covers how to find and handle them.
- Bark decay at the soil line. Penn State Extension names the decay fungi that move into a buried root collar: Phytophthora, Leptographium and Armillaria root rot.
- Slow decline. Crown dieback, thinning and poor growth, often years after planting.
Penn State’s warning is the one to remember: as decay works on a buried collar, the risk of the whole tree failing goes up “even as the crown of the tree is green and looks healthy.”
How do you check if your tree was planted too deep?
You need a long screwdriver and a hand trowel.
- Pull back the mulch and look at the base.
- Probe. Colorado State Extension suggests “a slender implement like a screwdriver” pushed into the soil 3 to 4 inches out from the trunk to find the first structural roots.
- Dig a test hole. Penn State Extension educator Thomas Ford uses “a small masonry trowel to carefully excavate the area around the trunk to a depth of 4–6 inches.”
- Stop around 8 inches. In the 2012 street-tree study, the Washington crew hand-dug root collars to a maximum of 8 inches, because “Further hand excavation would have caused more site disruption than was tolerable,” and the other sites used compressed-air excavation. That’s a sensible place for a homeowner to put the trowel down and call an arborist. (That cutoff is my own reading of the research method. No source states it as a rule.)
One trap: if the tree spent years under a mulch volcano, roots may have grown up into the mulch and soil above the real flare. Those surface roots are not the flare. The flare is where the trunk itself widens.
How do you fix a tree planted too deep?
A young or recently planted tree: replant it. Utah State University Extension says that for trees recently planted too deep, “your best option is to dig them up” and replant them correctly. Penn State recommends early spring or late fall, when the tree is dormant. In the Sacramento Valley, that’s roughly November through February. Dig the new hole only as deep as the root mass below the flare and two to three times as wide, set the flare 1 to 2.5 inches above grade as Utah State advises, and water it in. The Sacramento Tree Foundation’s quick check works well: lay a stake across the hole, and the flare “should be just in the middle of the stake.” A Radius Root Slayer shovel makes short work of digging around an established root ball.
An established tree: get the soil off the trunk. Penn State recommends hiring an ISA-certified arborist to do a root collar excavation with an air spade, which blows soil away without cutting roots. In an Ohio study, crews cleared soil from the flare out to an 18-inch radius. Set your expectations, though: in that four-year trial, “Seventy-five percent of the sites showed either no effect or a detrimental effect” from the excavation. Treat it as a way to get wet soil off the bark and find girdling roots. A tree that’s already declining may not bounce back.
After any excavation, keep mulch back off the trunk. Our guide to mulching a tree shows the flat ring that keeps the flare exposed.
What if soil gets piled on top of the roots?
This is the other way a tree ends up too deep, years after planting: a landscaper levels the lot, someone builds a raised bed against the trunk, or new sod goes down on a few inches of topsoil.
Colorado State Extension says that adding “only 4 to 6 inches of soil over an existing root system drastically reduces the amount of oxygen and water available to the roots,” and that tree wells “cannot compensate for the addition of soil over tree roots.” Iowa State puts the danger line at 4 or more inches of soil around a tree.
If a contractor suggests burying the trunk to level the yard, say no. Our page on landscaping around trees covers what you can do at the base without smothering the roots, and the cutting tree roots guide covers the other half of most grading jobs.
How do you plant the next tree at the right depth?
- Find the flare before you dig. Scrape soil off the top of the root ball until you find where the trunk widens. That’s your depth.
- Dig only as deep as the root mass. Measure from the flare to the bottom of the roots, and dig the hole no deeper than that. The pot’s height doesn’t count.
- Set it high. Flare at or just above the soil line. Utah State says 1 to 2.5 inches above grade.
- Strip the wrappings. On balled-and-burlapped trees, Colorado State says to remove the burlap, twine and wire basket from “the upper twelve inches or 2/3” of the root ball, whichever is greater. The Arbor Day Foundation says to cut the wire basket vertically and peel it away, and to remove vinyl or treated burlap completely.
- Ask the nursery. Penn State suggests asking whether root collars were exposed before trees were dug, and sliding a few trees out of their containers to look at the roots. Utah State recommends getting a written agreement to return a tree with a defective root system.
Our guides to how to plant a tree, root-bound nursery trees and planting bare-root trees cover the rest of planting day. For the first two summers, a soil moisture meter takes the guessing out of whether the root ball is drying out.
Frequently asked questions
What is a root flare? The root flare, also called the trunk flare or root collar, is the place where the trunk widens as it meets the main roots. On a properly planted tree you can see it at or just above the soil line. If the trunk goes straight into the ground like a post, the flare is buried.
How deep should the root flare be? At or just above the soil line, never below it. Utah State University Extension says to set the flare 1 to 2.5 inches above grade so the tree can settle, and the Sacramento Tree Foundation says at or just above the soil line.
How do I know if my tree was planted too deep? Look for a trunk with no flare at the base, then probe or dig. Colorado State Extension suggests probing 3 to 4 inches out from the trunk with a screwdriver to find the first structural roots. If you have to dig more than an inch or two to reach them, the tree is deep.
Can you fix a tree that was planted too deep? Yes, if you catch it early. A recently planted tree can be dug up and replanted at the right depth, which Utah State and UF/IFAS Extension both recommend. On an established tree, an ISA-certified arborist can remove the excess soil around the trunk with an air spade and check for girdling roots.
Is it safe to dig around the base of a mature tree? Hand-troweling a few inches down to look is reasonable. Penn State Extension’s root collar exam goes 4 to 6 inches deep with a small trowel. Digging deeper, or cutting any roots on a mature tree, is work for an ISA-certified arborist with an air spade.
The planting and care products linked across this site are collected in the Tree Planting and Watering Essentials list on my Amazon storefront.