Tree Topping: What It Does to a Tree and How to Fix a Topped One
Tree topping is cutting a tree’s branches back to stubs to make it shorter. The International Society of Arboriculture defines it as “the indiscriminate cutting of tree branches to stubs or to lateral branches that are not large enough to assume the terminal role,” and the problem is that it doesn’t work. A topped tree grows back fast, often taller and bushier than before, on weakly attached sprouts sitting on top of decaying stubs. Clemson Extension says topping is sometimes called a “ten year takedown,” because severely pruned trees often have to be removed within ten years.
If your tree has already been topped, it can often be brought back, slowly. If someone is offering to top it, there’s a better way to get the size you want.
What is tree topping?
Topping goes by a lot of names, which matters when you’re reading a tree service’s quote. The Arbor Day Foundation lists the synonyms: stubbing, heading, heading-back, stubbing-off, tipping, hatracking, topping-off, dehorning, lopping and roundover. If any of those words show up in a bid, it’s a topping job.
What separates topping from proper pruning is where the cut lands. The ISA’s rule: if a large limb has to be shortened, cut it back to a side branch “at least one-third the diameter of the limb being removed,” big enough to take over as the new leader. Penn State Extension’s example: a branch 3 inches in diameter gets pruned back to a side branch at least 1 inch thick. Cut to anything smaller, or to a bare stub, and you’ve topped it.

One look-alike to know: pollarding. The USDA Forest Service describes it as pruning trees annually to remove all new growth, a specialized practice started when the tree is young and kept up every year. It’s a deliberate system. Topping a mature tree once is not pollarding, even if the result looks similar for a season.
What does topping do to a tree?
It starves the tree. Leaves make the tree’s food. The ISA says topping can remove 50 to 100 percent of a tree’s leaf-bearing crown, and the tree has to burn stored energy to regrow leaves fast. The Arbor Day Foundation notes that good pruning rarely removes more than a quarter of the crown. Clemson adds that “Topping a severely stressed tree will usually kill it.”
It sunburns the bark. Bark that sat in the shade of the canopy for decades is suddenly exposed to full sun. The ISA lists sunburn, cankers and bark splitting among the results, something a Sacramento Valley tree in July does not need.
It opens the tree to decay. Big stub cuts are wounds the tree can’t seal off well. Penn State Extension warns that “Rotted limbs or the entire tree may fall years after it was topped.”
The regrowth is weak. The new sprouts grow fast, “as much as 20 feet (6 m) in one year in some species,” per the ISA, but they’re “anchored only in the outermost layers of the parent branches and are weakly attached.” Each one is a future branch failure sitting on a decaying stub.
It makes you liable. The ISA puts it bluntly: “Because topping is considered an unacceptable pruning practice, any damage caused by branch failure of a topped tree may lead to a finding of negligence in a court of law.”
It costs you value. Clemson says healthy, well-maintained trees can add 10 to 20 percent to a property’s value, while “Topped trees are considered an impending expense.”
Alex Shigo, the “world-renowned scientist and author of books on the care of trees,” called topping “the most serious injury you can inflict upon your tree,” as quoted by Penn State Extension.
Will a topped tree grow back?
Yes, fast, and not in the shape you wanted. Purdue Extension says that if topping doesn’t kill the tree, “topped trees regain their original height quickly, often within a year or two, depending on growing conditions.”
The Arbor Day Foundation’s year-by-year comparison:
- Year 1: “The topped tree is an ugly stub and a remnant of a once-lovely tree.”
- Year 3: “Vigorous sprouts have sprung out of the topped tree in large numbers and are growing with abnormal rapidity.”
- Year 6: the topped tree is as tall as it was to begin with, and in the bulletin’s words “far bushier and more dangerous.”
So the reason most people top a tree, to make it shorter and safer, falls apart within a few years. Some species don’t come back at all. The Arbor Day Foundation notes that beeches don’t sprout readily after severe pruning, and the lost foliage often kills the tree.
And even when it regrows, the ISA is clear: “A tree that has been topped can never fully regain its natural form.”
Can a topped tree be saved?
Often, if the tree is healthy and the decay at the old cuts hasn’t gone far. It takes patience and an arborist.
Oregon State Extension says the fix is to hire a certified arborist to remove excess branches and shorten others, and that a corrective project “is likely to require 3 years or so with the goal of returning the trees to a normal growth pattern.” A tree that was topped more than once takes longer.
Two rules keep restoration from becoming another round of damage:
- Don’t strip all the sprouts. They’re how the tree rebuilds its food supply. Colorado State Extension says that if a mature tree has many water sprouts, “leaving some is considered good practice.”
- Thin them gradually. Penn State Extension: “Remove no more than one-third of water sprouts in any one year.” Over a few seasons, the arborist keeps the best-placed sprouts on each stub to become new branches and removes or shortens the rest.
The tree will spend that whole time looking rough. That’s normal, and cutting it back harder to make it look tidy starts the cycle over.
When should a topped tree come out instead?
When it’s the wrong tree for the spot. The ISA says “Sometimes the best solution is to remove the tree and replace it with a species that is more appropriate,” and Purdue makes the same point: a tree that needs regular cutting to stay small is likely the wrong species for the site.
Removal also makes sense when the stubs have decayed into the trunk, when the species doesn’t resprout well, or when Clemson’s ten-year clock has mostly run out on a tree that was topped years ago. Our tree removal cost guide covers what that runs, and our guides to trees for small yards and trees to plant near the sidewalk cover what to put in its place.
What are the alternatives to topping?
If the tree does need to be smaller, ask for crown reduction instead. The Arbor Day Foundation describes it as cutting the tallest branches back to a large secondary branch so a leader remains, and says “When done correctly, crown reduction can be like a good haircut,” barely noticeable once it’s done.
Crown reduction has limits too. The USDA Forest Service calls it “a method of last resort” because it still leaves large wounds that can decay, and says the better long-term answer for a tree outgrowing its space is replacing it with one that fits.
How much to take off at once depends on who you ask:
| Source | Most foliage to remove at one time |
|---|---|
| Colorado State Extension | 10% of a mature tree per pruning cycle |
| Arbor Day Foundation | good pruning rarely removes more than a quarter of the crown |
| USDA Forest Service | no more than one-quarter of the living crown at a time |
Penn State notes that the old 25-percent-a-year guideline “is too broad to apply to all trees.” For a big, mature tree, I’d hold a pruner to Colorado State’s 10 percent.
Two more ways to keep a tree’s size in check, from the Arbor Day Foundation: start proper pruning while the tree is young, and “To slow the growth of a tree, avoid the use of nitrogen fertilizer.” Our guide on when to trim your tree covers the timing, and our loppers guide covers the tool for small reduction cuts. A sharp pair of Felco F21 bypass loppers and a Silky folding saw handle the cuts a homeowner should make from the ground. Anything bigger or higher belongs to an arborist.
Is utility pruning the same as topping?
No, even though the result can look harsh. When the power company clears trees from lines, it uses directional pruning: branches growing toward the wires get cut back to sound side branches. Penn State Extension says trees growing directly under the lines end up U or V shaped, and trees beside them end up L shaped, and that “tree topping is a prohibited practice” for line clearance.
So a lopsided V with clean cuts back to side branches is directional pruning. A tree rounded off with stubs all over the crown was topped, by whoever did it.
Topping near lines backfires on the utility too. Utah State University Extension describes topped trees under lines that “in one or two years” are back with sprouts in the wires and an unhealthy tree “fast on its way to becoming a hazard.” Its planting advice is the real fix: a small nursery tree “might end up being 60 feet tall and 30 feet” wide, so check the mature size before planting anywhere near a line.
How do you spot a tree service that tops trees?
The Arbor Day Foundation describes the pattern: so-called tree experts knock on doors, convince the homeowner the tree is a safety hazard, and offer their services “quick and cheap.”
What to do instead:
- Read the bid. Watch for heading, hat-racking, tipping, lopping, rounding over or “reduce height by X feet” with no mention of cutting to side branches.
- Hire an ISA-certified arborist. The ISA’s “Find an Arborist” and credential tools at TreesAreGood.org will confirm a certification. Our page on what an arborist does covers what the credential means.
- Get several quotes. Oregon State Extension suggests calling at least 3 companies, making sure the one you choose understands the project, and asking for before-and-after photos of past work.
- Ask how they’ll cut. “Back to side branches at least a third the size” is the answer you want.
Our tree trimming cost guide covers what proper pruning costs, and if a storm did the damage, our page on tree care after a storm covers what to do first.

If your problem is a crepe myrtle, the topped version has its own name, crepe murder, and our guide to trimming crepe myrtles covers how to prune one and how to bring a murdered one back.
None of this is new advice. The Arbor Day Foundation’s bulletin quotes John Davey, who put up $7,000 to print his book The Tree Doctor in 1901 and later founded the Davey Tree Expert Company: “Nature does not form those beautiful and health-giving tops of shade trees to be cut to pieces to furnish ‘beer money’ for a lot of tree fools.”
Frequently asked questions
What is tree topping? Topping is cutting a tree’s branches back to stubs, or to side branches too small to take over as the new top, to make the tree shorter. The International Society of Arboriculture defines it as “the indiscriminate cutting of tree branches to stubs or to lateral branches that are not large enough to assume the terminal role.” It also goes by heading, hat-racking, tipping, lopping and rounding over.
Will a topped tree grow back? It regrows fast, but not the same. Purdue Extension says topped trees often regain their original height within a year or two, as a dense mass of weakly attached sprouts. The ISA says a topped tree can never fully regain its natural form.
Can you top a tree to keep it small? Not without hurting it. Topped trees grow back quickly and need cutting again and again, and Clemson Extension says severely pruned trees often have to be removed within ten years. If a tree needs constant cutting to fit its spot, it’s the wrong tree for that spot.
Is utility line pruning the same as topping? No. Penn State Extension says utility directional pruning cuts branches back to sound side branches, leaving trees U, V or L shaped, and calls topping a prohibited practice for line clearance. A tree rounded off with stubs everywhere was topped.
How long does it take to restore a topped tree? Plan on years. Oregon State Extension says a corrective project by a certified arborist is likely to take 3 years or so to return a tree to a normal growth pattern. Penn State Extension says to remove no more than one-third of the water sprouts in any one year.
The planting and care products linked across this site are collected in the Tree Planting and Watering Essentials list on my Amazon storefront.